SynapticThe Next Computing Bill
Chapter 13 · Interactive edition

Who keeps the saving?

Medicare recovery accounts and a payments company’s annual report pose a question for the AI buyer. Once appeals, suppliers and internal work are paid, who keeps the money?

An auditor found an overpayment. A contractor collected money. An appeal gave some of it back. Each event happened to the same public buyer, and the first two would make excellent material for a sales presentation. The United States Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services published all three in an account that a prospective buyer of AI services might profitably take into a negotiation. For fiscal 2022 its fee-for-service recovery auditors collected $464.74 million in overpayments. The amount returned to the Medicare trust funds was $220.74 million. What happened to the other $244 million is a small education in the ownership of a result. 79

The program returned $41.94 million to providers that had been underpaid. Decisions overturned at the first level of appeal accounted for $115.70 million. The recovery auditors earned $72.94 million in contingency fees and the agency spent $13.42 million on administration. Subtract those four amounts from collections and the trust funds receive precisely the published balance. The contractor's revenue, the money properly due to providers and the public benefit all have names in this account. Applying the recovery figure to a technology supplier's sales forecast would give that supplier credit for money belonging to the Medicare trust funds, medical providers and program administrators. 79

There is even a fourth number a seller could have advertised. The auditors identified approximately $583.06 million in overpayments that fiscal year. Dividing collections by that figure gives about 80 percent. CMS reports an 83 percent recovery rate. Match cases across fiscal years. Cash from earlier determinations can reach the accounts this year. CMS describes negotiated fees and requires the contractor to give its contingency fee back when an improper-payment determination is overturned at any level of appeal. The rule reaches into cash already paid. Think about the difference that makes to a bidder deciding whether to take on a doubtful case in the last week of the quarter. 80

The same report describes a market that contractors declined. Recovery vendors found Medicare Part C audits commercially unattractive because payment arrangements differed and appeals could continue without a time limit. CMS used a different contracting arrangement to do the work. A laboratory selling accepted decisions faces the same question a bidder could ask here. How long after delivery can a challenge reach its balance sheet? Which result has the customer agreed to buy? Who pays to establish that it happened? For the prediction I am making about AI companies, the answers are worth more than a league table of model scores. 80

What a buyer can honestly claim

Klarna gives us a company with an actual AI deployment and enough public accounting to complicate an easy story. Management said the assistant powered by OpenAI handled 80 percent of customer service chats in 2025 and estimated approximately $59 million of cost savings that year. Customers could still reach a human. In the same filing, customer service and operations expense rose from $203 million to $207 million. A reader can believe both disclosures. The business processed 25 percent more transactions and its volume grew 32 percent. Providing a larger service cheaply can increase the amount a company actually spends. 81

The dates deserve a second look. The annual filing says repeat inquiries fell 25 percent between December 2023 and January 2024. It dates the launch to February 2024. Klarna’s May 2024 results announcement placed the launch in January. Neither document gives the deployment timetable by country and channel for the customers in that comparison or a repeat-inquiry rate for 2025. The expense line also covers work outside chat. A transaction can proceed without a conversation. To price the supplier’s share of the reported gain, an investor would need the contract fee, the accepted volume and the cost of serving those customers. Klarna’s estimate supplies none of those terms. 81 88

Consider what would persuade a bank's controller. She would want the number of cases received, the distribution of difficulty and the outcomes after customers had time to contest them. She would ask payroll which shifts were cancelled and procurement which contract stopped billing. Then she would ask the operating manager what happened to the freed hours. Perhaps an experienced clerk used them to investigate complaints that previously expired unanswered. That can be an excellent return on a purchase. On the day the clerk receives the same salary as before, the payroll saving is zero. The unanswered complaint and the salary both deserve a place in the decision.

Follow a case to its last owner

Take a fresh hypothetical purchase. A bank outsources evidence-file preparation for $100 per accepted file. The incumbent price includes the work needed to answer a challenge. Three bidders promise the same evidence, deadline, correction rights and access to a human. Each quotes $80 for a file finally accepted. A thousand files qualify each year for three years. The bank keeps its people and its ordinary overhead. After its own checks it regains twelve minutes of a clerk's time per file. At constant volume the bank removes $20,000 of external spending and gains two hundred staff hours each year. Its accounts show the first amount. Its service managers can put the hours to work.

Exhibit 31 / Settlement model

The settlement of a hundred dollars

Follow the same hundred dollars through three accounts. Turn the desk to inspect each layer or change the contract that funds it.

Settlement plateLaboratory leads
Buyer cash kept · $20$20BANKCloud purchase · $15$15CLOUDVerification · $10$10Manual completion · $5$5Qualification · $6$6Laboratory · $38$38LABDelivery specialist · $6$6FINAL USESBuyer cash kept · $20$20BANKCloud purchase · $15$15CLOUDDelivery specialist · $27$27DELIVERYLaboratory · $38$38LABPRIME SETTLEMENTBuyer cash kept · $20$20BANKAccepted service · $80$80SERVICEBUYER BUDGET

Each strip uses the same dollar scale. Read from the buyer's budget at the top to final uses at the bottom.

Bank saves$20
Lab contribution$38

200 staff hours a year, with $0 removed from payroll. External cash saved at the same volume equals $20,000 a year.

Figure 31. Illustrative three-year service at constant annual volume and quality. Each transparent layer describes the same money at a different stage. The middle layer divides the prime's receipt after its immediate payments. The lowest layer separates direct costs and supplier contributions. An owner funding a loss is shown as a separate source. Amounts are rounded for display.
Download evidence and assumptions (CSV)

Begin with the laboratory as principal supplier. Every file gets one automated run. One in four needs a second attempt. The laboratory buys computing capacity at $12 an attempt and reimburses a specialist for verifying each attempt at $8. Independently of that retry classification, one in ten files needs a manual finish costing $50. A human completing a retried case earns that fee for different work. The bank pays once for the accepted outcome. In a thousand cases there are 1,250 cloud charges, 1,250 verification charges, 100 manual finishes and 1,000 customer invoices if the files are billed separately. Aggregate billing changes the paperwork and leaves those quantities intact.

The specialist advances $18,000 to qualify the service, recoverable in equal annual instalments across the three-year term in our calculation. At a thousand files a year this absorbs $6 per accepted file. The specialist also earns $6 per file for coordinating delivery after recovery of its specified costs. Its average invoice to the lab is consequently $27. Checking takes $10, manual completion $5, qualification $6 and coordination accounts for the remaining $6. The lab pays $15 for computing power. Against its $80 sale it therefore keeps $38 toward model development, general overhead, financing, taxes and whatever profit survives those expenses. Calling the full $80 a margin would erase two suppliers.

The date on the cheque matters to the specialist. In the first year it collects $27,000, pays $10,000 for checking and $5,000 for manual work, and advances the entire $18,000. Its cash balance from this assignment is negative $6,000 before other expenses. In each of the next two years the same annual receipts and ordinary costs leave $12,000. Across the full term the specialist has earned $18,000 for coordination. If the buyer cancels after twelve months, the specialist may have financed a deployment whose remaining instalments never arrive. The party that advances the money has a perfectly good reason to ask who pays the remaining qualification balance at termination.

Working backward from the bank's original hundred gives a further check. Twenty stays with the buyer. Fifteen reaches the infrastructure company. Ten funds checking, five covers manual completion and six recovers the initial outlay. The specialist retains six and the lab retains thirty-eight. Those amounts sum to one hundred. An economist could follow the infrastructure company's own electricity, equipment and wages another level down. At this boundary the cloud purchase is a single outside cost. Adding its employees' wages to the hundred after including the cloud bill would count some of the same money twice. Each layer of the illustration repartitions the preceding one.

Bad runs have a creditor

An output contract changes the consequences of a difficult Tuesday. Under our terms the bank pays the same $80 for an accepted difficult case as for an ordinary one. The cloud supplier charges for both attempts and the checker must inspect both. The delivery specialist recovers those costs. The lab has effectively written the bank a small insurance policy on the difficulty of the incoming work. It can do this profitably when easy cases fund hard ones. To price the promise it needs the distribution of retries and the cost of finding out that a seemingly convincing first answer was wrong.

Exhibit 32 / Cost sensitivity

The price of a failed run

How much can the contract owner spend checking each attempt before it loses money on an accepted file?

Checking cost per attempt · USD$0$10$20$30$40$500%25%50%75%100%-$40-$20$0+$20+$40Files requiring one extra attempt
Break-evenLossSelected terms

Laboratory leads. At 25% retries, delivery breaks even at $38.40 of checking per attempt. At the selected $8 check, its contribution is $38 per accepted file.

$80 accepted price − ($12 cloud + $8 checking) × 1.25 attempts − $5 manual − $6 qualification − $6 coordination = $38.

Maximum verification cost at zero delivery contribution
Files with a second attemptUSD per attempt
0%$51
25%$38.40
50%$30
75%$24
100%$19.50
Figure 32. Each line holds the owner's contribution constant as checking cost and retry frequency change. Above the gold boundary the signed price fails to cover delivery. The specialist incurs the qualification, verification and manual costs. When subcontracted it passes those amounts on and receives $6 for coordination. Price, volume and manual fallback follow the settlement plate. The model assumes every file ultimately meets the same acceptance terms.

At the original retry frequency the lab breaks even on delivery when checking reaches $38.40 an attempt. The arithmetic starts with the $80 sale, reserves $5 for fallback, $6 for qualification and $6 for the specialist's coordination. That leaves $63 to fund 1.25 attempts. Each could cost $50.40 altogether before the lab's residual disappears. The machine already takes $12 of that. Now move to a portfolio where sixty percent of files need another attempt and each check costs $30. Attempts consume $67.20 per accepted file. Add the other $17 and the lab loses $4.20 on each delivery. The bank still receives its $20 discount. The signed price determines who finances that result.

Difficulty often arrives in batches. A single employer might submit a year's worth of irregular records just before a deadline. That produces a queue of precisely the files likely to need a second look. An annual average can price the labour while concealing a week in which no experienced checker is free. The bank's recourse might be to reopen the old service at an emergency rate. A credible bid states who staffs the peak, which party pays for an overflow desk and how a case moves there without losing the evidence already collected. Those are economic terms even when procurement puts them in a service appendix.

Cheap verification can disguise a different cost. Suppose the bidder proposes to sample fewer files. Its contribution rises immediately in the model if the buyer holds accepted quality constant. Whether that assumption survives a trial depends on errors among the cases nobody chose to examine. Have an independent reviewer draw a random sample from the apparently clean files as well as inspecting the obvious exceptions. Follow reopened cases to an agreed maturity date. Separate confirmed errors from changes in policy. Charge the review to the party that commissioned it. A price comparison across bids then has a common basis for calling a file complete. A fast first answer is worth exactly what that evidence says it is worth.

A workable contract gives each accepted file a reference that follows a subsequent complaint. It gives the buyer a period to challenge the file and specifies the remedy if the challenge succeeds. A replacement report might restore the promised service. It may also arrive after the bank has paid compensation to its customer. The contract must say who bears that second loss. Otherwise the cheap bidder can exclude a serious expense that another bidder has included in its fee. An early trial can test this clause without waiting for a catastrophe. Give every bidder the same previously overturned file and ask its commercial director to price the correction against the proposed terms.

The company whose name is on the contract

Now put the same work through three different owners. Keep every volume, price to the bank and quality requirement fixed. Where another party leads, the lab offers its runs wholesale at $24 an attempt and pays its own $12 cloud charge. At 1.25 attempts it receives $30 and retains $15 per accepted file. When the specialist leads, it collects $80 from the bank, pays $30 to the lab and covers $21 of checking, manual work and qualification. It keeps $29. Compare its $6 when it worked for the lab. The extra compensation pays for risks that arrive with its signature.

Exhibit 33 / Three operating contracts

Three owners of the workflow

The bank buys the same accepted file in all three contracts. Compare what the laboratory bills and what it keeps after direct delivery costs.

Contract ownerUSD per accepted file$0$20$40$60$80$100LabSpecialistIncumbent
Lab revenueLab contribution

A wholesale lab receives $30 for 1.25 attempts. It pays $15 for cloud. A lab leading the contract collects $80 for the accepted file.

Same price, volume and service · USD per accepted file
PrimeLab revenueLab contributionSpecialist contributionIncumbent contribution
Laboratory$80$38$6$0
Specialist$30$15$29$0
Incumbent$30$15$6$23

For each bid the buyer keeps $20, the cloud supplier earns $15 and the three bidders' contributions sum to $44.

Figure 33. Square marks show what the laboratory earns for its specified service. Circles deduct its own delivery costs. The prime controls and supplies the completed file under the assumed contract. A specialist or incumbent prime buys attempts wholesale from the lab and bears the cost of additional runs. Contributions exclude shared overhead, financing, tax and model development. Principal and agent guidance · A distributor's reported figures

Put the incumbent software company in charge. It receives $80, pays $30 for the lab's wholesale service and $27 for the specialist's work. It retains $23. Across the three routes the customer saves the same $20 and the three bidders together retain the same $44 before unallocated costs. Yet the laboratory reports $80 of revenue as prime and $30 as a wholesale supplier under the assumed contracts. Its contribution changes from $38 to $15. A price cut by the lab on wholesale attempts could make the incumbent's route more attractive while leaving the bank's bill untouched until the next renewal. A competitive response can transfer money between sellers before a customer sees a cent.

An accountant would first inspect the promise that each seller controls. The IFRS Interpretations Committee examined a software reseller that advised a customer and arranged delivery of standard licences. Its May 2022 decision asks what good or service the customer was promised and whether the reseller controlled it before transfer. Responsibility for fulfilment, inventory risk and discretion over price can help resolve that question. Their weight depends on the facts. Our prime assumes responsibility for the integrated file, contracts the inputs and delivers the accepted work. A broker who collects $80, owes $74 to the actual provider and earns a $6 arranging fee presents a different transaction. Putting the whole collection into that broker's sales would radically distort its apparent scale. 82

Consider a listed distributor with real numbers. Climb Global Solutions reported 2025 gross billings of about $2.105 billion and net sales of $652.5 million. Gross billings, a company-defined operating measure, includes the gross value of certain transactions for which revenue is recorded net. Billings grew 18 percent and net sales grew 40 percent. The same company, during the same period, produced two defensible growth rates for different purposes. Neither difference measures an AI margin. A prediction that an AI computing company can outgrow a cloud company has to specify which reported measure crosses which line. The face value of every invoice passing through a distributor would set a wonderfully easy hurdle to clear. 83

Read the second order

Double the bank's volume to two thousand files in each year of the term. The $6,000 annual qualification allocation now costs $3 per file. Under the lab-led price and cost reimbursement above, the specialist's invoice falls from $27 to $24 per case. The lab's contribution rises from $38 to $41 and its annual revenue reaches $160,000. If the bank would have bought all two thousand files at the old price, it saves $40,000. If it would only ever have bought the first thousand, the extra thousand purchase work that previously went undone. The old $100,000 budget has grown to $160,000. Better service may justify every dollar of that expansion.

Volume can fall too. At five hundred files a year qualification absorbs $12 a case and the lab's contribution drops to $32. A seller anticipating that exposure may offer the bank a lower unit price in exchange for a minimum annual purchase. The buyer accepting the minimum then acquires some of the demand risk that previously sat with the laboratory. Look for a line in the purchase order showing the payment due if the bank tenders fewer files than expected. In a quiet year, dividing the cash actually paid by the files actually accepted will reveal an effective price quite different from the prominent figure on the opening page.

At renewal I would ask for two lists. The first identifies the old contracts, shifts or charges that actually disappeared and the buyer who can confirm their removal. The second identifies work the customer can now afford, its recipients and what happened after delivery. A vendor with durable pricing power ought to be able to produce examples from both lists. Once a customer knows how much of the saving it can keep and how many additional cases that saving buys, the negotiation changes. The company that can quote the next accepted case, pay for a bad run and stand behind its answer has earned a credible claim on the next order.

Sources and reading notes

  1. 79 · CMS, Medicare fee-for-service recovery audit program, FY2022 appendices

    Appendix B reconciles overpayments collected, underpayments restored, first-level appeals, contractor fees and program administration to $220.74m returned to trust funds. A public operating account for a specific year. No AI attribution.

  2. 80 · CMS, Medicare and Medicaid integrity programs, FY2022 report to Congress

    Section 4.2.1 describes negotiated recovery fees, their return after an appeal and independent validation. Identifying an overpayment differs from collecting it.

  3. 81 · Klarna Group, 2025 Form 20-F

    Operating expenses and operating leverage discussions, especially pp. 132–134 and 184–185. Management estimates $59m of 2025 assistant savings. Customer service and operations expense rose $4m to $207m. The model supplier's fee is undisclosed.

  4. 82 · IFRS Interpretations Committee, software reseller decision, May 2022

    IFRS 15 B34–B38 require identification of specified goods or services and assessment of control before transfer. The indicators require judgment under each contract.

  5. 83 · Climb Global Solutions, full-year 2025 results

    FY2025 net sales $652.5m and gross billings $2.105bn. The company's operating definition of gross billings includes values of certain transactions reported net in revenue. Company-wide figures span several products and contract types.

  6. 88 · Klarna, first-quarter 2024 results announcement, 30 May 2024

    Management dates the assistant launch to January 2024. The 2025 Form 20-F gives February and reports a December-to-January repeat-inquiry comparison. Neither account supplies the exposure dates of the comparison cohort.